6 Trips Available

from

$1075

Guides > Captain Larry Wren

First Choice Charters

5 10 reviews Identity VerifiedIdentity Verified

Islamorada FL

Guidesly Guarantee
Guides > Captain Larry Wren

First Choice Charters

locationIslamorada FL

Guidesly Guarantee
5 10 reviews

Your Captain

guide pic

Larry Wren

Identity Verified

Larry Wren, Captain at First Choice Charters

If you're searching for top-tier Islamorada fishing charters that combine local expertise with a laid-back, family-friendly vibe, you're in for a treat with First Choice Charters. Whether you're chasing your first trophy fish or coming back for round two, every trip is packed with action and coastal charm.


Sailing from the world-famous fishing grounds of Islamorada and Key Largo, you'll be casting lines in waters teeming with life. These warm, tropical seas have earned the Florida Keys its well-deserved title as the Sportfishing Capital of the World. With Islamorada fishing charters and Key Largo fishing charters, you'll have direct access to fast-moving pelagics and reef dwellers alike. Think Mahi Mahi, Sailfish, Tuna, Snapper, Wahoo, and more — with each trip offering something unique depending on the season and the sea.


The vessel you’ll be fishing from is a beautifully restored 37’ Merritt sportfishing boat. Originally built in 1958 and modernized in 2011, she blends classic design with reliable power and comfort. Outfitted with twin Cummins 355HP engines and a wide-open fishing deck, she offers enough room for six anglers to fish side-by-side — no tangles, no crowding, just smooth sailing. Whether trolling offshore or dropping lines near the reef, this boat is fully equipped for any style of sportfishing adventure.


Target species vary by season and style, but one thing’s consistent — Capt. Larry’s dedication to putting you on the fish. From high-speed trolling for King Mackerel to bottom fishing for Grouper and Yellowtail Snapper, there’s never a dull moment. Looking to target big-game predators? You can take on Marlin, Tuna, and even set out on a dedicated Swordfishing trip. During the right times of year, kite fishing for Sailfish becomes the highlight of the trip, offering a challenge that’ll have your adrenaline pumping.


With over 15 years of guiding experience and a Blue Star certification for sustainable fishing practices, Capt. Larry is as passionate about conservation as he is about catching fish. He’s patient, knowledgeable, and especially great with families — there’s no minimum age for kids, and he’s happy to adapt the trip to your group’s needs. Whether you're a die-hard angler or just looking to enjoy a memorable day on the water, First Choice Charters delivers a professional, approachable, and exciting experience with some of the best Islamorada fishing charters in the Keys.

Show more>

Upcoming Availability

July 2025
August 2025

Expertise & Attributes

fishing

fishing

Deep Sea FishingDeep Sea FishingGood with FamiliesGood with FamiliesGood with KidsGood with KidsGood with Large GroupsGood with Large GroupsGood with New AnglersGood with New AnglersLive BaitLive BaitMaster GuideMaster GuideNature / Wildlife ViewsNature / Wildlife ViewsSaltwater FishingSaltwater Fishing

Fishing Techniques

Trolling FishingFly FishingHeavy TackleLight TackleDeep Sea / Bottom FishingKite Fishing

What's Included

Good to Knows

Good to Knows

Your Guide has some important details about your trip with them.

Show More

Cancellation Policy

Cancellation Policy

When you book your fishing trip, you will need to first put down a deposit to hold the reservation.

Show More

What's Included

Good to Knows

Good to Knows

Your Guide has some important details about your trip with them.

Show More

Cancellation Policy

Cancellation Policy

When you book your fishing trip, you will need to first put down a deposit to hold the reservation.

Show More

Trips Available with First Choice Charters

Private 4 Hour Family Friendly Fishing Charter - Islamorada

Fishing

Starting At $1,075

Private 4 Hour Family Friendly Fishing Charter - Islamorada

Fishing: Offshore

Fishing Boat:

First Choice • 37' Merritt • Max 6 guests (base trip price includes 6 guests)

Description:

Kick off your morning with a 4-hour Islamorada fishing charter that begins at 7:00 AM. This half day trip is ideal for families, beginners, or anyone looking to enjoy a relaxing experience on the water without committing to a full day. You’ll fish the productive nearby waters of Islamorada, where Snapper, Barracuda, and Sailfish (seasonally, in winter) are commonly targeted. There’s no age requirement for kids, making it a great introduction to fishing for young anglers. Parents should bring life vests for children under 6. All fishing gear and licenses are included, and Captain Larry is happy to accommodate guests with special needs.

Please note: Mahi are not targeted on half-day trips from May to October.

Private 6 Hour Offshore fishing charter - Islamorada

Fishing

Starting At $1,400

Private 6 Hour Offshore fishing charter - Islamorada

Fishing: Offshore

Fishing Boat:

First Choice • 37' Merritt • Max 6 guests (base trip price includes 6 guests)

Description:

Start your day at 7:00 AM with a 6-hour Islamorada fishing charter designed for anglers who want more time on the water and a shot at bigger fish. This trip takes you 10 to 20 miles offshore, where you’ll target species like Sailfish, Kingfish, Wahoo, Swordfish, Barracuda, and more, depending on the season. It’s a great option if you’re looking to go beyond the quick morning bite but not commit to a full day. All fishing gear and licenses are included, and Captain Larry ensures a smooth and safe trip for all guests. If there are any special needs in your group, please let the Captain know in advance.

Note: A 20% gratuity is customary and payable to the captain after the trip.

Private 8 Hour Deep Reef and Offshore Islamorada Charter

Fishing

Starting At $1,900

Private 8 Hour Deep Reef and Offshore Islamorada Charter

Fishing: Offshore

Fishing Boat:

First Choice • 37' Merritt • Max 6 guests (base trip price includes 6 guests)

Description:

This 8-hour Islamorada fishing charter begins at 7:00 AM and takes you to deep reefs ranging from 500 to 1,000 feet. These depths are home to some of the finest-tasting fish in the ocean. Using advanced electric reels or traditional hand cranks, you’ll drop lines to target deepwater species prized for their flavor and fight. This trip can also be customized to include offshore trolling, giving you the chance to target pelagic fish like Kingfish or Wahoo, depending on conditions. With all gear and licenses provided, it’s a well-rounded trip for anglers looking to explore different techniques and zones in a single outing.

Private 8 Hour Kite Fishing Charter - Islamorada

Fishing

Starting At $1,900

Private 8 Hour Kite Fishing Charter - Islamorada

Fishing: Offshore

Fishing Boat:

First Choice • 37' Merritt • Max 6 guests (base trip price includes 6 guests)

Description:

Join our full-day Islamorada fishing charter for a seasonal kite fishing experience available from November 1 through April 1. Designed specifically for targeting Sailfish, this specialty trip offers an exciting opportunity to watch these powerful fish strike live bait right at the surface. With kites flying high and lines set just right, this technique creates one of the most visually exciting moments in sportfishing. The trip includes freshly caught bait and Google Eyes to maximize your chances of success. Availability depends on weather and sea conditions, so flexibility is key for the best possible experience.

Private Full Day Islamorada Offshore Fishing Charter

Fishing

Starting At $1,600

Private Full Day Islamorada Offshore Fishing Charter

Fishing: Offshore

Fishing Boat:

First Choice • 37' Merritt • Max 6 guests (base trip price includes 6 guests)

Description:

Experience a full day on the water with this action-packed Islamorada fishing charter, where you'll fish anywhere from 3 to 40 miles offshore. With a wide range of species in the mix—like Sailfish, Wahoo, Kingfish, Barracuda, and more—you’ll have plenty of chances to hook into something memorable. This trip is perfect for anglers ready to cover more water and explore some of the most productive fishing grounds in the Florida Keys. All licenses and fishing equipment are provided, and Captain Larry ensures a comfortable, safe, and well-guided trip for all.

Important: A 20% gratuity is customary and should be given to the captain at the end of the trip.

Private Extended 12 Hour Swordfish Fishing Charter - Islamorada

Fishing

Starting At $2,000

Private Extended 12 Hour Swordfish Fishing Charter - Islamorada

Fishing: Offshore

Fishing Boat:

First Choice • 37' Merritt • Max 6 guests (base trip price includes 6 guests)

Description:

Head 28 miles offshore on this 12-hour Islamorada fishing charter targeting the legendary Swordfish. Departing at 7:00 AM, this extended trip is for serious anglers ready to take on one of the ocean’s most powerful deepwater predators. The boat is equipped with electric reels to help manage the heavy lifting and long battle these fish demand. During summer, the return ride offers a chance to troll for Tuna or other surface-feeding species depending on conditions. This all-day trip combines deep drops and surface action for a complete offshore experience.

Please note: A 20% gratuity and a 10% fuel surcharge apply.

Vehicle

First Choice

Boat Type:

Boat Guest Capacity:

6

Boat Length:

37 ft

Manufacturer Name:

Merritt

Model Year:

1960

Engine Manufacturer Name:

Cummins

# of Engines:

2

Horsepower Per Engine:

355

Maximum Cruising Speed:

28

Features: Fighting Chair Bait Tank Outriggers Flybridge Toilet Fish Finder GPS VHF Radio

First Choice Charters Merritt Boat

Step aboard with Capt. Larry on his classic 37’ Merritt, a vintage offshore sportfishing boat built in 1958 and beautifully restored in 2011. With a wide, open deck that accommodates up to six anglers comfortably, and powered by twin 355HP Cummins engines, she offers a smooth, stable ride offshore.

Boat

First Choice Charters Merritt Boat image 0

First Choice

Boat Type:

Boat Guest Capacity:

6

Boat Length:

37 ft

Vehicle Details

FAQs about First Choice Charters

Ratings & Reviews Summary

5.00
out of 5
Based on 10 ratings
100%
recommended
recommended
Based on 10 recommendations
5
10
4
3
2
1

July 5, 2025

Our captain was awesome and hit all the spots! Snapper & Grouper! Highly recommend if you’re in Destin Fl. Thank you 1st Choice Charters my family had a great time.

July 5, 2025

Had a great time, highly recommend! Such an enjoyable experience. The guide will take you around and back safely.

July 5, 2025

Captain Larry and our mate Travis were awesome! They put us on fish and helped us catch. We had a great day on the water catching a variety of fish, including some big Mahi and a number of nice black fin tuna for the dinner table! The boat was super comfortable, too! They did everything to make sure we had a great time. Thanks guys!

July 5, 2025

We just had an awesome fishing experience with Captain Larry today! We have chartered boats all over the world and this ranks as definitely one of the very best! I don't agree at all with the one star review! Capt. Larry was super friendly and knowledgeable and his mate, Colby was awesome and worked nonstop. We caught a sailfish and 6 other kinds of fish and both guys were great! It was a great day, we already recommended Capt. Larry to family who are coming down In a couple months and will be booking with him our next trip to the keys.

July 5, 2025

Captain Larry went above and beyond to make our experience truly memorable. We got tuna, Thank you, Captain Larry! Our adventure was amazing and thank you for letting me lift up that ginormous amberjack. That was fun! I could barely hold onto that slippery sucker! And we got sharks too! šŸ¦ˆšŸ™šŸŒŠ

July 5, 2025

Capt Larry and first mate Eric worked tirelessly to make sure my sons, sons-law and brothers-in-law (total of 5 of us) had a great experience! We had a blast bringing in fish as fast as we could on a couple of spots. These spots were found by the captain by knowing where to look for fish. Those two (Larry and Eric) seemed to be having as much fun as we were and worked hard to help us fish as much as possible. They cleaned / fillet our fish and recommended a place to take them for dinner. I highly recommend First Choice .

Captain Fishing Species

Loading...