Your Captain
Jeff Conroy
Identity Verified
Get ready for an unforgettable fishing adventure on Lake Ontario with J&J Sportfishing Charters, based in Mexico, NY! Led by Captain Jeffrey, a seasoned local expert, and his experienced father-son crew, J&J Sportfishing Charters provides the ultimate way to experience the lake’s premier fishing grounds. With over a decade of Lake Ontario fishing under their belts, the crew is dedicated to making every trip as thrilling and rewarding as possible, whether you're new to fishing or a seasoned angler.
You’ll be boarding “The Bearded Clam,” a well-equipped 27' Penn Yan sportfishing vessel with ample room for up to four passengers. This classic fishing boat is equipped with all essentials, including downriggers and high-quality rods, reels, and tackle, so you’ll have everything you need for a successful day on the water. For your convenience, there’s a clean, onboard restroom to keep you comfortable for a full day of fishing. Families are welcome, and J&J Sportfishing is a kid-friendly charter, so it’s the perfect opportunity to introduce younger anglers to the thrill of the catch. If you’re bringing kids, the crew will ensure safety and fun, even offering child-sized life vests if needed.
The fishing season with J&J Sportfishing offers plenty of variety and excitement. From March to May, enjoy the best of Brown Trout and Lake Trout fishing, ideal for early-season anglers. As the season progresses from June through September, you’ll have the chance to target King Salmon, Brown Trout, Lake Trout, Steelhead, and even Chinook and Pink Salmon if conditions are favorable. With the captain’s extensive knowledge, you’re likely to experience trolling and other effective techniques tailored to each species. Every trip is designed to maximize your chances of a big catch while creating an experience that’s both fun and educational.
Before your trip with J&J Sportfishing, be sure to get a local fishing license, as New York requires one for all anglers. The J&J team can guide you on any species restrictions. Essentials to bring include a hat, sunglasses, bottled water, non-spray sunblock, and snacks to stay energized. Alcohol is permitted in moderation, but avoid glass bottles and hard liquor for safety.
Enjoy a complete experience on Lake Ontario with a helpful First Mate who can assist and clean your catch; a 10-20% tip is customary. Ready to reel in big memories? Join J&J Sportfishing for a fantastic day on the water!
What's Included
This guide offers trips that you are able to take home your catch.
Your Guide has some important details about your trip with them.
Show More
This guide offers trips with nature and wildlife views.
When you book your fishing trip, you will need to first put down a deposit to hold the reservation.
Show More
What's Included
This guide offers trips that you are able to take home your catch.
Your Guide has some important details about your trip with them.
Show More
This guide offers trips with nature and wildlife views.
When you book your fishing trip, you will need to first put down a deposit to hold the reservation.
Show More
Pick Your Date
Pick Your Date
Start your private 6-hour Lake Ontario fishing trip at 5:00 AM with space for up to 4 anglers, priced at $700. Guided by an experienced captain, you’ll target Chinook Salmon, Brown Trout, and Lake Trout using proven trolling techniques. Beginners will find this trip approachable, while seasoned anglers can still enjoy the challenge of hooking trophy-sized fish. The waters of Lake Ontario are known for producing quality catches, giving your group a rewarding day on the lake. All fishing gear is included, so you can focus on the experience. Deposits are non-refundable (Trips & Rates Page)
Pick Your Date
Start your private 6-hour Lake Ontario fishing trip at 5:00 AM, priced at $700 for up to 4 guests. This trip is designed with families in mind, offering a safe and enjoyable way to target Chinook Salmon, Brown Trout, and Lake Trout. The captain provides all gear and guidance, making it easy for both adults and kids to participate and have fun. Trolling in some of the lake’s most productive waters gives your family the chance to reel in quality fish together. Whether it’s your first time or you’ve fished before, the focus is on creating lasting memories on the water. Deposits are non-refundable (Trips & Rates Page)
Pick Your Date
Start your private 6-hour Lake Ontario fishing trip at 5:00 AM, priced at $700 for up to 4 anglers. This trip is tailored for skilled anglers who want to target Chinook Salmon, Brown Trout, and Lake Trout with precision and strategy. Using advanced trolling methods and expert guidance, you’ll work the productive waters where trophy fish are often caught. The captain provides top-quality gear, ensuring you can focus on technique and maximizing results. Designed for those who enjoy a challenge, this trip highlights both the sport and the reward of Great Lakes fishing. Deposits are non-refundable (Trips & Rates Page)
Pick Your Date
The Bearded Clam
Boat Type:
Boat Guest Capacity:
4
Boat Length:
27 ft
Manufacturer Name:
Penn Yan
Model Year:
1976
Engine Manufacturer Name:
Ford
# of Engines:
2
Horsepower Per Engine:
235
Maximum Cruising Speed:
20
Features: Toilet Fish Finder GPS
This classic 27’ Penn Yan sportfishing boat seats up to 4 guests, powered by twin 235HP Ford engines for a smooth ride at 20 knots. Perfect for small-group fishing adventures!
The Bearded Clam
Boat Type:
Boat Guest Capacity:
4
Boat Length:
27 ft
Vehicle Details
We had the case of the dropsey this weekend we still pulled together a decent box of fish we ened the trip getting 7 keepers and throwing 2 back and dropping 10 more we still have dates open for July if you want in on this give us a call or text at 315 567 5487 or at 570-557-9210 or message us on Facebook
Sorry for the late post but Friday and Saturday were alittle slow for us but still managed to get so nice fish even a 15 pound brown we still have some dates open if you want in on this give us a call or text at 315 567 5487 or at 570-557-9210
What a great day to be on the water and a bad day to be a brown the bit is on if you want in on this give us a call and get in on it 315 567 5487 or at 570-557-9210 or message us on Facebook
What a action packed weekend lots of bits but keeping them button was the trick all in all a great time on the water thanks everyone that came out and fished with us we still have dates available if you want in on this give us a call or text at 315 567 5487 or at 570-557-9210 or message us on Facebook
It was a slow pick for us on Saturday but we managed to get a couple plus one great steelhead we still have available dates if you want to get in on this action befor the ened give us a call or text at 315 567 5487 or at 570-557-9210 or message us on Facebook
What a great day on the water with the boys from Massachusetts getting it done going 7 for 17 in the morning for the first trip the 2nd trip was much slower for us tho with the guys from camp only boating 3 out of 6 fish we still have dates available for this month give us a call or text at 315 567 5487 or at 570-557-9210 to get in on this action
The bite is on, and it’s another Full Box Friday on Lake Ontario! Anglers had an incredible day reeling in limits of lake trout and salmon, with steady action from start to finish. The fish are hitting strong, and the warmer spring temperatures are setting up ideal conditions for an even better season ahead. Whether trolling deep or working the shallows, the fish are active and ready to put up a fight! With spring and summer dates filling fast, now is the time to book your Lake Ontario fishing charter. Don’t miss out on the chance to land trophy lake trout and hard-fighting salmon. Secure your spot today and get ready for an unforgettable day on the water!
It was a grind this weekend but boy did you laugh and laugh it was a great group of guys from PA we still have available dates this month and September give up a call or text at 315-402-6120 or 570-557-9210 or text up on Facebook
Ratings & Reviews Summary
October 6, 2025
I’ve been fishing with J & J Sportfishing for almost 10 years and several trips per year. They always do everything they can to make your day enjoyable and catch the most fish!! We almost always catch our limit and have a blast! I highly recommend these guys for your next fishing adventure!!
October 6, 2025
Went with a group of guys from work we had a great time they got us on fish pretty quick and we're right there to give us pointers on how to land the fish planning on doin it again in the future and would recommend them to others
October 6, 2025
We had an absolute blast with these guys. We caught a lot of fish and had a lot of laughs!!!
October 6, 2025
Had an amazing trip full of action—don’t wait to book!
October 6, 2025
Jeff and Jeff were fantastic hosts—accommodating, personable, and wonderful with our kids. We shared plenty of laughs and caught some fish along the way. I’ll definitely be booking another trip with them. Thanks again, guys!
October 6, 2025
We had an absolute blast with these guys. We caught a lot of fish and had a lot of laughs!!!