Montauk Charter Boats - Shark Fishing
Private Trip
Offshore Fishing
Target Mako and Thresher sharks in Montauk watersAccommodates up to 6 guests on offshore fishing adventureProfessional photo opportunities with trophy catches at dock
Ready to go toe-to-toe with some of the ocean's most legendary predators? Lady Grace Sport Fishing Charters takes you straight into Montauk's prime shark waters, where the Atlantic's apex hunters cruise the deep blue looking for their next meal. This isn't your typical day of fishing – we're talking about hooking into blues, threshers, and makos that'll test every ounce of your angling skills. With room for up to 6 anglers, you'll have plenty of space to work these powerful fish without bumping elbows. The best part? These sharks don't just fight like freight trains – they're also fantastic on the dinner table. Plus, nothing beats that dock-side photo with a toothy grin next to your catch of a lifetime.
We're heading offshore into Montauk's productive shark grounds, where the continental shelf drops off and the big fish patrol. The trip starts early – shark fishing is all about timing and being where the fish are when they're actively feeding. You'll spend your day in some of the East Coast's most renowned shark territory, with Lady Grace's experienced crew guiding every aspect of your hunt. The atmosphere is electric once we get lines in the water and start the waiting game. Shark fishing requires patience, but when that reel starts screaming, all that waiting pays off in spades. The crew keeps things organized and safe while you focus on the fight of your life. Between hookups, you'll enjoy the camaraderie that comes with shared anticipation and the stunning views of Montauk's coastline from the offshore perspective.
Shark fishing is all about the chum slick and heavy tackle. We'll set up a proper chum line using fresh bunker and other oily baits to draw sharks from miles around. The scent trail acts like a dinner bell, pulling these apex predators right to our spread. We fish with circle hooks on heavy wire leaders – these sharks have razor-sharp teeth that'll slice through mono in a heartbeat. The rods are serious pieces of equipment, rated for big fish and long fights. We'll deploy multiple baits at different depths, from just below the surface down to 50 feet or more. Fresh bluefish, mackerel, and bunker chunks make prime shark candy. The key is keeping that chum flowing and staying patient – sharks move on their own schedule. When one shows up, you'll know it. The takes can be subtle or explosive, but once you're hooked up, it's all about smooth drag pressure and letting the fish run when it wants to run.
Blue sharks are the workhorses of Montauk shark fishing. These sleek, indigo-colored predators show up consistently throughout the season and put up a solid scrap on medium-heavy tackle. They're curious fish that respond well to chum, often circling the boat multiple times before committing to a bait. Blues typically run 50 to 150 pounds in these waters, with their torpedo-shaped bodies built for speed and endurance. They're active from late spring through fall, with peak action during the warmer months when baitfish are abundant.
Thresher sharks are the acrobats of the bunch, famous for their impossibly long tail fins that can equal the length of their body. These fish are absolute rockets when hooked, known for spectacular jumps and blistering runs that'll have your drag singing. Threshers use that whip-like tail to stun schools of baitfish, making them incredibly efficient hunters. They prefer the cooler waters of early morning and evening, and catching one is considered a real trophy among shark anglers. Most threshers in our waters range from 100 to 200 pounds, with their unique profile making them instantly recognizable.
Shortfin mako sharks represent the ultimate prize in Montauk's offshore waters. These are the Formula One cars of the shark world – built for pure speed and capable of reaching 40+ mph when they want to run. Makos are notorious for their aerial displays, launching completely out of the water in spectacular fashion. They're also considered the best eating of all shark species, with firm, white meat that tastes more like swordfish than traditional shark. Makos are less predictable than blues but show up consistently enough to keep things interesting. When you hook a mako, you're in for the fight of your life – they're smart, strong, and absolutely relentless.
This top-rated shark fishing adventure combines world-class angling with the chance to land genuine trophy fish that'll have you telling stories for years. Lady Grace Sport Fishing Charters brings the local knowledge and professional equipment you need to make the most of Montauk's legendary shark grounds. Whether you're after that perfect photo, a fantastic dinner, or simply the rush of battling one of nature's most efficient predators, this trip delivers on all fronts. The small group size ensures personalized attention and plenty of fishing time for everyone aboard. Don't wait – Montauk's shark season is prime right now, and these spots fill up fast with returning customers who know what kind of action these waters can produce.
Get ready to target Mako and Thresher sharks aboard our well-equipped 6-passenger charter boat in Montauk waters. This motorboat comes loaded with everything serious anglers need - GPS navigation to find the hottest fishing spots, radar for those foggy offshore runs, and a fish finder to locate your next trophy. Stay comfortable during long battles with onboard air conditioning, plus VHF radio keeps you connected to the fleet. When nature calls between fights, there's a head onboard. Our experienced captain knows where these apex predators cruise and will put you on the fish. Whether you're looking to put shark steaks on the dinner table or snap that perfect photo with your catch back at the dock, this charter delivers the goods. Montauk's offshore waters are legendary for big sharks, and our boat gets you there in comfort and style.
Prionace GlaucaBlues are one of the most beautiful sharks you'll see off Montauk - deep blue backs fading to bright white bellies. They're built for speed with that torpedo shape, typically running 7-10 feet and 60-200 pounds depending on sex. Females get much bigger. We find them in deeper water, usually 1,000+ feet out in the canyons where they hunt squid and small tuna. Best fishing is summer through early fall when water temps hit that sweet spot of 54-68°F. They're curious sharks that come to chum readily, making for steady action. The fight isn't as wild as a mako, but they're scrappy and make great photos. Pro tip: keep your chum line at least 20 feet from the boat - blues can get aggressive in a feeding frenzy and you don't want one body-slamming your transom.
Isurus OxyrinchusMakos are the ultimate shark challenge - fastest in the ocean at 30+ mph and they'll jump 20 feet when hooked. These blue-gray rockets average 13 feet and 130-300 pounds, hunting everything from tuna to dolphins in open water. We find them near the surface in deep water, sometimes dropping to 400+ feet. Summer's prime time when they follow the warm water up from the south. What sets makos apart is pure adrenaline - they're aggressive, smart, and will use every trick including your own boat to break free. The meat's outstanding too, almost swordfish-like. We chum heavy with ground mackerel and tuna, then fish live bluefish on circle hooks. Critical tip: once you hook up, watch that fish like a hawk. Makos will circle your boat to snap the line or even jump aboard if they're mad enough. Keep at least 50-pound tackle and wire leaders.
Alopias VulpinusThreshers are the showstoppers out here - that tail can be as long as their body, sometimes reaching 8 feet on a big fish. Average thresher runs 16 feet and 500 pounds, but we've seen monsters push 20 feet. They use that whip-like tail to stun baitfish at 50mph before eating them. You'll find them 40-50 miles offshore in 200-2,000 feet of water during late spring through fall. What makes them special is the fight and the jumps - they'll clear the water completely when hooked. Plus they're excellent eating, some of the best shark meat you'll try. We target them by drifting with mackerel or sardines, keeping baits 25-50 feet down. Here's the key: use smaller 8/0 hooks despite their size - threshers have surprisingly small mouths. Heavy braid and a long wire leader are must-haves for these powerful fish.
Syosset, NY