Montauk Charter Boats - Shark Fishing
Private Trip
Offshore Fishing
Target Mako and Thresher sharks in Montauk waters offshore.Accommodates up to 6 guests per charter trip.Fresh shark meat provides excellent table fare postcatch.
When you're looking for that heart-pounding action that only comes from battling apex predators, Lady Grace Sport Fishing Charters delivers the goods right here in Montauk's legendary shark-infested waters. This isn't your typical day of pulling in fluke—we're talking about going toe-to-toe with some of the Atlantic's most powerful fighters. Picture yourself cranking on a 30-pound class rod while a mako goes airborne just 50 yards off your stern, or feeling that slow, heavy pull of a thresher shark making its dive for the depths. With space for up to 6 anglers, you'll have plenty of room to work the fish without bumping elbows, and trust me, when these sharks start running, you'll want all the deck space you can get.
Your day starts early with a steam out to the productive waters off Montauk Point, where the continental shelf drops into the deep blue that these sharks call home. Captain and crew know these waters like the back of their hands—they've been putting clients on trophy sharks for years, reading the currents, temperature breaks, and bird activity that signal where the action's happening. The vibe on board is all business when it comes to safety and fish-finding, but relaxed enough that first-timers won't feel overwhelmed. You'll spend most of your time in 80-200 feet of water, though don't be surprised if we push out deeper when conditions are right. The boat's equipped with top-shelf electronics to mark bait schools and structure, plus all the heavy tackle you need to handle whatever shows up. Most trips run 6-8 hours, giving you plenty of time to work different spots and techniques until we find what's biting.
Shark fishing is all about heavy gear and patient presentations. We're talking 50-80 pound class conventional reels spooled with braided line, paired with stout rods that can handle the punishment these fish dish out. The crew rigs everything with circle hooks and wire leaders—this isn't bass fishing, and one wrong move with regular mono will leave you telling stories about "the one that got away." Most of the action happens while drifting with chunked bunker, bluefish, or fresh caught bait. We'll set up a proper chum slick to draw sharks in from miles away, then deploy 4-6 baits at different depths to cover the water column. When a shark picks up your bait, there's no mistaking it—these fish don't nibble. The rod doubles over, line starts screaming off the reel, and suddenly everyone on board is wide awake. Fighting technique matters here: pump and wind, keep steady pressure, and let the drag do its job when the fish makes those bone-jarring runs.
Blue sharks are the bread and butter of Montauk shark fishing, showing up consistently from June through October in good numbers. These sleek, indigo-colored predators typically run 50-150 pounds and are absolute acrobats when hooked. Don't let anyone tell you blues are boring—a 100-pound blue shark will test your tackle and your endurance in ways that'll surprise you. They're curious fish, often circling the boat before committing to a bait, giving everyone a chance to see them in the clear water. Thresher sharks are the holy grail for many anglers, with their distinctive elongated tail fin that's as long as their body. These fish are pure muscle, running anywhere from 75-300 pounds, and they fight deep and dirty. When a thresher grabs your bait, expect a long, grinding battle that'll leave your arms feeling like jelly. Best action typically happens from July through September in deeper water. Shortfin mako sharks represent the ultimate challenge—they're the fastest shark in the ocean and arguably the hardest fighting fish you'll encounter off Montauk. Makos are explosive fighters, known for their spectacular jumps and blistering runs that can strip 200 yards of line in seconds. These torpedo-shaped predators range from 60-400 pounds, with the bigger females showing up in late summer. Landing a mako is a badge of honor that separates casual anglers from serious shark hunters.
If you've been thinking about stepping up your fishing game and targeting some serious predators, this charter delivers exactly what you're looking for. Lady Grace Sport Fishing Charters has built their reputation on consistently putting anglers on quality shark action, and their knowledge of Montauk's waters gives you the best shot at hooking into the fish of a lifetime. Whether you're looking to check sharks off your bucket list, introduce experienced anglers to something new, or just want bragging rights at the dock, this trip has it covered. The season's prime time is happening right now, and the bite reports have been solid. Don't wait until the end of season when weather becomes a factor—book your date and get ready for some of the most exciting fishing the Northeast has to offer.
This well-equipped motorboat gets you out to prime shark territory off Montauk with all the essentials for a successful day on the water. The 6-person capacity keeps your group comfortable while you battle Makos and Threshers in deep offshore waters. Air conditioning provides relief between fights, while the fish finder helps locate the action beneath the surface. GPS navigation and radar ensure safe passage to productive fishing grounds, even when visibility drops. The VHF radio keeps you connected to other boats and shore, plus there's a head onboard for those long days chasing sharks. With everything you need to land your trophy and snap that perfect dock photo, this boat delivers the real deal for serious shark fishing adventures off Long Island's eastern tip.
Prionace GlaucaBlues are probably the most gorgeous sharks you'll encounter off Montauk. These torpedo-shaped beauties show off that classic deep blue topside fading to white underneath. They typically run 7-10 feet and 60-200 pounds, though females get much bigger. You'll find them cruising 20-40 miles offshore in deeper water, usually around 100-400 feet down. They're curious by nature, which makes them great targets for drift fishing with chum. Summer through early fall gives you the best shot at them when water temps hit that sweet spot. Blues put up a solid fight and make for great photos, plus the meat's actually pretty good. Pro tip: keep your chum line at least 20 feet from the boat - these guys can get worked up and you don't want one deciding to visit the deck uninvited.
Isurus OxyrinchusMakos are hands down the fastest sharks in the ocean, hitting 30+ mph and jumping 20 feet out of the water. These metallic blue torpedoes average 10-13 feet and 130-300 pounds, with that distinctive pointed snout and razor-sharp teeth. They roam the open ocean from surface down to 400 feet, following the warm water and baitfish. Summer and early fall are your best bets when water temps are right. What sets makos apart is their intelligence and pure aggression - they'll test every piece of your gear and then some. The fight is legendary, but so is the table fare - some of the best shark meat you'll ever taste. Here's what I've learned: use circle hooks and heavy wire leaders because they're smart enough to bite through anything lighter. Most importantly, stay alert when you get one boatside - they've been known to jump right into the cockpit.
Alopias VulpinusThreshers are the acrobats of the shark world with those massive whip-like tails that can match their body length. These blue-grey beauties average around 16 feet and 500 pounds, making them a serious trophy catch. They cruise the continental shelf about 40-50 miles out, anywhere from surface down to 200 feet, hunting schools of mackerel and bluefish. Late spring through fall is prime time here in Montauk waters. What makes threshers special is watching them use that tail to stun baitfish - it's like nothing else out there. They're also known to jump completely clear of the water during fights. The meat's top-notch too. My go-to setup is trolling with mackerel or sardines, but here's the key: use 8/0 hooks since their mouths are surprisingly small for such big fish. Heavy tackle is a must - these guys hit 30mph when they want to.
Syosset, NY