/310x340/users/5a323a96-e570-4e72-ac84-8fbba6997fdb/images/fishing-cruises-oh-2655.jpg)
/310x340/users/5a323a96-e570-4e72-ac84-8fbba6997fdb/images/best-great-fishing-expedition-oh-2602.jpg)
/310x340/users/5a323a96-e570-4e72-ac84-8fbba6997fdb/images/cruising-casting-conneaut-fishing-2424.jpg)
/310x340/users/5a323a96-e570-4e72-ac84-8fbba6997fdb/images/cruises-fishing-conneaut-2665.jpg)
/310x340/users/5a323a96-e570-4e72-ac84-8fbba6997fdb/images/successful-fishing-conneaut-2481.jpg)
Your Captain
/310x340/users/5a323a96-e570-4e72-ac84-8fbba6997fdb/profile/1759443887345-mg9zu2rz.jpg)
Jim Holtzman
Identity Verified
Makin’ Memories Fishing Charters invites anglers to experience unforgettable Lake Erie fishing charters, targeting trophy Walleye, Yellow Perch, and Steelhead. Known as the Capital of Walleye, Lake Erie offers some of the best fishing places on Lake Erie, where anglers can consistently find large, healthy fish. Captain Jim Holtzman, who has pursued trophy fish since his childhood alongside his father, knows the waters intimately and will guide you to the spots where success is almost guaranteed.
Fishing aboard the 30’ Cherokee offshore sportfishing boat, Makin’ Memories, guests enjoy a safe and comfortable experience. With 12’ beams and a spacious deck, the boat accommodates six guests and crew without feeling crowded. Equipped with state-of-the-art fishing and navigation tools, every Lake Erie fishing charter combines comfort, safety, and efficiency, ensuring you spend more time catching fish and less time worrying about logistics.
Captain Jim Holtzman’s decades of experience include tales from the era of the legendary Blue Pike, and his deep understanding of Lake Erie’s ecosystem allows him to track the seasonal Walleye migration. With over 60 years of fishing the Great Lakes, he provides insight and guidance that ensures a rewarding trip. Visitors often discover that knowing the best time for Walleye fishing on Lake Erie can make all the difference between an average day and a trophy catch.
Makin’ Memories Fishing Charters provides everything you need for a great fishing day, including live bait, lures, rods, reels, and tackle. After your trip, local bait shops can clean and fillet your catch for a small additional fee. Book your adventure today and discover why anglers consider Lake Erie one of the best fishing places on Lake Erie, where incredible Walleye and other species are waiting for you.
What's Included
Your Guide has some important details about your trip with them.
Show More
When you book your fishing trip, you will need to first put down a deposit to hold the reservation.
Show More
What's Included
Your Guide has some important details about your trip with them.
Show More
When you book your fishing trip, you will need to first put down a deposit to hold the reservation.
Show More
Take part in a 7-hour Morning trolling trip on Lake Erie, available June 1 to October 1, targeting Walleye with artificial and live bait. Departing at 5:00 AM, this guided trip allows anglers to handle rods and operate fishing equipment while learning trolling techniques from the crew. Designed for all skill levels, the experience emphasizes active participation and provides practical instruction to improve fishing ability. Gear, bait, and guidance are included, ensuring guests have everything needed for a productive Walleye trip. This afternoon option offers both learning opportunities and rewarding fishing.
Pick Your Date
Take part in a 7-hour afternoon trolling trip on Lake Erie, available June 1 to October 1, targeting Walleye with artificial and live bait. Departing at 3:00 PM, this guided trip allows anglers to handle rods and operate fishing equipment while learning trolling techniques from the crew. Designed for all skill levels, the experience emphasizes active participation and provides practical instruction to improve fishing ability. Gear, bait, and guidance are included, ensuring guests have everything needed for a productive Walleye trip. This afternoon option offers both learning opportunities and rewarding fishing.
Pick Your Date
Experience an 8-hour drifting fishing trip on Lake Erie, available June 1 to July 13, targeting Walleye with both artificial and live bait. Departing at 5:30 AM or 3 PM, this guided trip is suitable for anglers of all skill levels. Guests actively handle rods and equipment while learning practical drifting and light rod techniques from experienced crew members. The trip emphasizes hands-on participation, offering detailed tips and tricks to improve skills and confidence on the water. Gear, guidance, and instruction are included, making this an ideal trip for anyone looking to fully engage in a Walleye fishing adventure.
Pick Your Date
Join a 4-hour Lake Erie Steelhead fishing trip, running September 25 to October 8, designed for anglers of all skill levels. Departing in the afternoon around 3 PM, this guided trolling trip targets Steelhead (Rainbow Trout) using artificial bait. Guests actively handle all rods and equipment under expert guidance, learning practical techniques and tips to improve fishing skills. The crew ensures hands-on involvement throughout, creating an engaging and educational experience. Gear, instruction, and fishing expertise are included, making this trip ideal for both beginners and seasoned anglers.
Pick Your Date
Join an 8-hour morning trolling trip on Lake Erie, running June 1 to October 18, targeting Walleye and Rainbow Trout during peak activity hours. Departing at 5:30 AM, this guided trip covers a large area of the lake using artificial and live bait. Guests actively handle rods and equipment while learning trolling techniques under expert guidance. The experience emphasizes hands-on participation, providing practical tips to improve fishing skills. Gear, instruction, and guidance are included, making this trip suitable for anglers of all skill levels and focused on maximizing both learning and catch potential.
Pick Your Date
Join an 8-hour morning fishing trip on Lake Erie, offered from September 15 to October 8, targeting Walleye or Yellow Perch depending on current conditions. Departing at 5:30 AM, this flexible charter allows the captain to decide on the day whether to pursue Walleye or Perch, ensuring the best opportunity based on the bite. Guests will fish with artificial and live bait, covering productive grounds with guidance from the crew. All gear and instruction are included, making this a hands-on trip suitable for anglers of any skill level who want to experience two of Lake Erie’s most popular fisheries.
Pick Your Date
Join Captain Jim Holtzman for a 2-hour Lake Erie sunset cruise, departing 1 hour before sunset from June 1 to October 1. This seasonal trip accommodates up to six guests on the 30-ft Cherokee sportfishing boat, offering a safe and relaxing ride. While no fishing is included, passengers can enjoy calm waters, scenic views, and a guided tour of Lake Erie’s shoreline. All safety equipment is provided, and booking includes free cancellation with three days’ notice. This cruise is suitable for all skill levels and is ideal for families, friends, or small groups seeking an evening on the water.
Pick Your Date
Makin' Memories
Boat Type:
Boat Guest Capacity:
6
Boat Length:
30 ft
Manufacturer Name:
Cherokee
Model Year:
1989
Engine Manufacturer Name:
Chevrolet Crusader
# of Engines:
2
Horsepower Per Engine:
230
Maximum Cruising Speed:
35
Features: Toilet Fish Finder GPS Radar
/fit-in/340x340/users/5a323a96-e570-4e72-ac84-8fbba6997fdb/vehicle_picture/326301395_573886277936643_6915831202975345973_n1-mga02m8d.jpg)
The 30-ft Cherokee sportfishing boat, built in 1989, comfortably accommodates 6 guests. Powered by twin 230HP Chevrolet Crusader engines, it reaches speeds up to 35 knots. Designed for offshore sportfishing, it combines stability, performance, & plenty of deck space for a top-tier fishing trip.
/fit-in/260x260/users/5a323a96-e570-4e72-ac84-8fbba6997fdb/vehicle_picture/326301395_573886277936643_6915831202975345973_n1-mga02m8d.jpg)
Makin' Memories
Boat Type:
Boat Guest Capacity:
6
Boat Length:
30 ft
Vehicle Details
Ratings & Reviews Summary
November 17, 2025
If you want to be kept involved in a great fishing experience, then this is the trip for you. Mariah and Jimmy will keep you completely engaged in the best experience that I have ever had with any charter.
November 17, 2025
I HAD BOOKED A CHARTER WITH ANOTHER CAPTAIN BUT HE REPLIED HIS MOTOR WAS DOWN . SO I BOOKED WITH JORDANNY AND HIS BROTHER AND BOY WERE WE GLAD. THEY WORKED LIKE A FINE OILED MACHINE . WE CAUGHT A 25-30 POUND WAHOO AND ABOUT 9 TUNA FROM SMALL TO AROUND 3-4 POUNDS. SO IF YALL ARE LOOKING FOR A EXCELLENT CHARTER WITH A RELIABLE CREW AND FRIENDLY PEOPLE THIS IS IT. THANX TO JORDANNY AND HIS BROTHER ARCHIE . CHEERS AMIGOS
November 17, 2025
Fantastic time with a fantastic crew! Capt. Jimmy always finds his fish! Spacious boat and up to date gear. Will definitely book again!!
November 17, 2025
We had the best time with Captain Jim and his first mate. We caught a ton of fish and always felt safe.
November 17, 2025
This charter boats name exemplifies it all! Hands down the best charter boat and captain in Northeast Ohio. You are all but guaranteed to have a good time and likely catch your limits of Walleye! I have been on charters with him for 35 years and never am dissapointed.
November 17, 2025
Hands down one of the best fishing trips you can take! We’ve been out with captain Jim multiple times and caught out limit every time