Next AvailableNov 21

Book with Justin Irving

Guides > Captain Justin Irving

Over The Rail Sportfishing

4.92 13 reviews Identity Verified

Pulaski NY

Justin Irving, Captain at Over The Rail Sportfishing

Experience the thrill of fishing like never before with Over The Rail Sportfishing on Lake Ontario. Led by the knowledgeable and professional guide, Captain Justin Irving, you'll have the opportunity to reel in the catch of a lifetime while learning his secrets of success.


Climb aboard the reliable and spacious 26-foot Penn Yan 265 Pro Hunter, one of the most comfortable fishing platforms in the area. This impressive vessel can accommodate up to 6 guests, ensuring you have plenty of room to fish without bumping elbows. Equipped with state-of-the-art electronics, radar, and an onboard head (toilet) for your convenience, the Penn Yan 265 Pro Hunter will enhance your fishing experience.


Join Over The Rail Sportfishing and explore the vast waters of Lake Ontario, where you'll come face to gills with a variety of fish species. Whether it's the thrill of hooking a Trophy Trout or battling a feisty Salmon, your fishing expedition is bound to be unforgettable. Captain Justin Irving's expertise and local knowledge will guide you to the best fishing spots, increasing your chances of landing a prized catch.


No matter your age or level of experience, everyone is welcome aboard Over The Rail Sportfishing. Make it a family outing, invite your friends, or even bring along your co-workers for a memorable day on the water. Captain Justin is dedicated to creating a fun-filled environment where everyone can learn and enjoy the thrill of fishing.


As you embark on your fishing adventure, Captain Justin will take care of all your fishing needs. From providing top-quality bait to assisting with tackle selection, he ensures you have everything necessary for a successful day on the water. After the excitement of reeling in your catch, Captain Justin will also clean and fillet your fish, so you can take home your well-deserved rewards.


To enhance your experience, pack your favorite snacks and drinks to enjoy while you fish. With Over The Rail Sportfishing, you can relax, unwind, and savor the excitement of angling in one of the most beautiful locations on Lake Ontario.


Over The Rail Sportfishing guarantees to hook you up with the biggest bites, making your fishing adventure on Lake Ontario an incredible and rewarding experience. Don't miss the opportunity to fish with Captain Justin Irving and discover why Over The Rail Sportfishing is renowned for providing unforgettable fishing trips on Lake Ontario.

Show more>

Upcoming Availability

Trips Available with Over The Rail Sportfishing

CAPTAIN FOR HIRE

Fishing

Starting At $200

CAPTAIN FOR HIRE

Fishing Area: New York

Fishing: Lake

Capacity:

Max 8 guests (base trip price includes 8 guests)

Description: Are you looking to step up your fishing game? Have Captain Justin come aboard your boat and help dial it in to get you catching more fish! Captain Justin will go over all the equipment, and boat layout to ensure your setup is the most productive possible.

Guided Ice Fishing Trips

Fishing

Starting At $350

Guided Ice Fishing Trips

Fishing Area: New York

Fishing: Lake

Capacity:

Max 10 guests (base trip price includes 10 guests)

Description: Are you ready to brave the cold and catch some fish? Over The Rail Sportfishing offers this ice fishing trip for various species on many bodies of water throughout New York and Massachusetts. Our fishing guide will take you on an adventure like no other, where you can experience the thrill of catching fish through a hole in the ice. All our trips are customized and include All gear, shanty, heater, tackle, and bait to enjoy a successful day on the hard water! Due to varying Ice Conditions contact us to discuss available water bodies! Book today!

Lake Ontario Fishing Charters

Fishing

Starting At $500

Lake Ontario Fishing Charters

Fishing Area: New York

Fishing: Lake

Fishing Boat:

Penn Yan 265 Pro Hunter • 26' Penn Yan • Max 6 guests (base trip price includes 6 guests)

Description: If you're looking for the best Lake Ontario fishing charter, look no further than Over The Rail Sportfishing! This half to full day Lake Ontario trolling trip takes anglers out onto the stunning waters of Lake Ontario in search of some of the world's most impressive fish, including salmon and trout. Whether you're a seasoned pro or a first-time angler, this trip is guaranteed to leave you with memories that will last a lifetime. All fishing gear included! Don't forget to pack your drinks and snacks and bring your fishing license too! Book now!

Shared 6 Hour AM Salmon Trout Trip

Fishing

Starting At $175

Shared 6 Hour AM Salmon Trout Trip

Fishing Area: New York

Fishing: Offshore

Fishing Boat:

Penn Yan 265 Pro Hunter • 26' Penn Yan • Max 6 guests (base trip price includes 6 guests)

Description: This is an open boat shared charter trip. This is ideal for those who want to book a trip but are unable to pay full price themselves or get a group to split the costs. This allows you to reserve an individual seat on a shared trip with up to 4 guests. The Captain reserves the right to cancel the trip or reschedule if there are not enough guests to fill the boat. This will be done in numerous days advance of the trip so you will not show up to the dock and be canceled upon arrival if there are not enough guests.

6 Hour PM Shared Trip Salmon Trout

Fishing

Starting At $175

6 Hour PM Shared Trip Salmon Trout

Fishing Area: New York

Fishing: Offshore

Fishing Boat:

Penn Yan 265 Pro Hunter • 26' Penn Yan • Max 6 guests (base trip price includes 6 guests)

Description: This is an open boat shared charter trip. This is ideal for those who want to book a trip but are unable to pay full price themselves or get a group to split the costs. This allows you to reserve an individual seat on a shared trip with up to 4 guests. The Captain reserves the right to cancel the trip or reschedule if there are not enough guests to fill the boat. This will be done in numerous days advance of the trip so you will not show up to the dock and be canceled upon arrival if there are not enough guests.

fishing Territory

FAQs about Over The Rail Sportfishing

Ratings & Reviews Summary

4.92
out of 5
Based on 13 ratings
100%
recommended
recommended
Based on 13 recommendations
5
12
4
1
3
2
1
Our Captain is loved for...
Best Boat
Great For Top Anglers
Great Guide
Good with Kids
Best Spots
B
BrianDaniels

November 21, 2024

I don’t think there’s words to say how great of a trip we had. Once we started gearing up to fish, we were on fish. Cap. Justin was very knowledgeable with the area, how and where we needed our lures, and most importantly how to not lose a fish. We will definitely be coming back for future trips. This was our first trip on Lake Ontario and I feel the best we could ever have. 

November 21, 2024

Captain Justin took my family out for my bachelor party this past weekend, and I can't say enough about how great of a guide he is. My whole family can't stop talking about how much fun we had, and how we can not wait to go back. We truly had an experience that none of us will ever forget. Justin is very knowledgeable, patient, and works his butt off to make sure that your trip is successful. I'm so glad that we booked our trip with Over The Rail. I couldn't have asked for a better captain. Hopefully we see you again soon, Justin!

JL
Jessica Lopez

November 21, 2024

Let me just say that the waves were choppy and both My Husband and I got motion sickness(bummer, we forgot to take meds for it!) But of course that wasn’t Captain Justin’s fault. He was very knowledgeable and answered all our questions. We felt comfortable  and right at home! We will definitely be coming back for more and we refuse to be out there with anyone else! Thank you Captain Justin👍

November 21, 2024

Awesome time with justin, owner of over the rail. Very knowledgable and great attitude. 5 stars all the way! Will he booking next years trip very soon.

P
PrestonRobbins

November 21, 2024

Great captain to fish with! Highly recommended if you’re looking for a great outing, not just with the fishing but also the relaxation and great conversations!

B
BrianLaDue

November 21, 2024

We couldn't have asked for a better day! Or a better captain! Can't wait to go again next year