Susquehanna River Calico Trip
Private Trip
River Fishing
Beginnerfriendly Susquehanna River fishing with expert Captain AllenTarget calico, rock bass, crappie, sunfish, and yellow perchSmall group experience with maximum two guests per trip
Looking for a solid day on the water that delivers consistent action? Captain Allen's Calico Trip on the Susquehanna River hits the sweet spot for anglers who want variety without the hassle. This isn't about chasing trophy bass or wrestling with massive catfish – it's about filling your day with steady bites, learning the river's personality, and walking away with a cooler full of pan fish that'll make for some fine eating. Whether you're just getting your feet wet in the fishing world or you've been working these waters for years, this trip brings something special to the table.
The Susquehanna River runs deep with character, and Captain Allen knows every bend, eddy, and honey hole that holds fish. Your day starts early – that's when the fish are most active and the river's at its best. With just two spots on the boat, you're getting personalized attention that bigger charters just can't offer. Allen's been guiding these waters long enough to read the river like a book, adjusting tactics based on weather, water levels, and what the fish are telling him. The beauty of targeting calico and company is that when one species goes quiet, another usually picks up the slack. You'll move between different structures – rocky points, submerged timber, and shallow flats – keeping things interesting all day long. The river's current adds a nice challenge to your presentation, teaching you to work with the water instead of fighting it. Expect to cover some ground, but don't worry about long runs between spots – the Susquehanna holds fish in countless pockets, so you're never far from the next bite.
This style of fishing is all about finesse and reading what the fish want. Captain Allen sets you up with light to medium tackle that lets you feel every nibble while still having enough backbone for the occasional surprise. You'll be working small jigs, live bait rigs, and soft plastics – nothing fancy, but everything has a purpose. The key is learning to feel the difference between your sinker bumping bottom and a fish picking up your bait. These species can be subtle biters, especially the crappie, so Allen teaches you to set the hook on anything that feels different. Depending on the season and conditions, you might be fishing shallow structure in a few feet of water or working deeper holes where the fish stack up. The river's rocky bottom means you'll lose some tackle – that's just part of the game – but Allen keeps plenty of rigs tied and ready. Bait presentation matters here, and you'll learn how to keep your offering in the strike zone while dealing with current and wind. It's the kind of fishing that makes you a better angler, teaching patience and technique that transfers to any water you fish.
Redbreast Sunfish are the stars of the show and for good reason. These colorful fighters pack serious attitude into a compact package, often running 6-8 inches with the occasional slab pushing 10. They love rocky areas with current breaks and aren't shy about hitting your bait. What makes them special is their aggressive nature – once you find a school, you can often catch several before they wise up. Best fishing happens from late spring through early fall when they're active in the shallows, guarding beds or chasing baitfish. The Susquehanna's redbreast have that deep orange belly that makes them stand out, and they fight harder than their size suggests.
Rock Bass might not win beauty contests, but they're reliable producers that keep your rod bent. These chunky fighters typically run 8-10 inches and have mouths bigger than you'd expect, so don't be afraid to upsize your bait. They stack up around boulder fields and bridge pilings, making them perfect targets when you find the right structure. Spring and fall are prime time, but they'll bite year-round if you put your bait in their face. What anglers love about rock bass is their willingness to bite – they're not finicky about presentation and will often hit when other species turn their nose up at your offering.
American Yellow Perch bring that classic schooling behavior that can turn a slow day into fish-catching mayhem. When you find them, they're usually in groups, and the action can be fast and furious. These striped beauties typically measure 7-9 inches in the Susquehanna, with some reaching respectable 11-12 inch sizes. They prefer slightly deeper water with soft bottom and scattered structure. Late fall and winter are peak times, but they can be caught throughout the season if you know where to look. Perch are excellent table fare, making them a favorite for anglers who like to keep a few for dinner.
Crappie round out the slam and bring their own unique challenge. These paper-mouth fighters require a gentle touch – too heavy on the hookset and you'll tear the hook right out. Susquehanna crappie run smaller than lake fish but make up for it with numbers. They suspend around structure and can be picky about depth, so Allen uses his electronics to pinpoint schools and drop baits right on their noses. Spring is prime time when they move shallow to spawn, but you can catch them year-round by adjusting your depth and presentation. Their light bite and tendency to just swim away with your bait makes them a great teaching fish for developing better angling skills.
Captain Allen's Calico Trip delivers exactly what it promises – consistent action, personalized instruction, and a day on the water that reminds you why you started fishing in the first place. With only two anglers per trip, you're not fighting for attention or prime spots on the boat. The Susquehanna River offers world-class panfish action that flies under the radar while everyone else chases bass and muskie. This top-rated experience works for complete beginners who need to learn the basics and seasoned anglers looking to dial in their light tackle skills. The variety keeps things interesting, the scen
Perca FlavescensYellow perch are schooling fish that travel in big groups, so when you find them, you're in for some fast action. They average 7-8 inches with those classic yellow sides and dark vertical stripes. Look for them around weedy areas, docks, and drop-offs where they cruise hunting minnows and insects. Spring and fall are prime time when they move shallow to feed, but you can catch them year-round if you know where to look. What guests love most is the non-stop action once you locate a school - it's not uncommon to catch 20-30 in a trip. They're also some of the finest eating fish in the river, with sweet white meat that's hard to beat. My go-to setup is ultralight tackle with small jigs or live minnows. Once you hook into one, keep your bait in that same area because the rest of the school is right there with them.
Pomoxis NigromaculatusCrappie are the prize of our panfish trips - they grow bigger than most sunfish and have some of the best table fare you'll find. We catch both black and white crappie here, running 9-12 inches on average. They love structure like submerged trees, brush piles, and deeper weed edges, usually holding 8-15 feet down. Spring spawning season is hot when they move shallow, but fall fishing can be even better when they school up tight. What makes them special is that perfect combination of good size, great fight on light tackle, and outstanding eating quality. They're also smart fish that require some finesse. The key is using small jigs or live minnows and working them slow around cover. Once you dial in the depth they're holding, you can catch them steady. Remember, crappie are most active at dawn and dusk.
Lepomis AuritusRedbreast sunfish are some of the prettiest fish you'll catch on the Susquehanna, especially the males with their bright red bellies and those distinctive long black "ear" flaps. Most run 6-9 inches, perfect panfish size. They love shallow rocky areas and vegetated pools, staying close to cover where they hunt insects and small crayfish. Spring through early fall gives you the best action when water temps hit that 65-75 degree sweet spot. What makes them fun is their scrappy fight on light tackle - they'll bend that rod nicely for their size. Plus, they're some of the best eating you'll find in freshwater. Pro tip: when you're fishing around rock piles or fallen timber, use a small jig or live cricket and let it settle right next to the structure. They can't resist it.
Ambloplites RupestrisRock bass might not be true bass, but don't let that fool you - these goggle-eyed fighters are aggressive and fun to catch. They typically run 6-8 inches with those big red eyes that give them away every time. You'll find them around rocky bottoms, fallen trees, and dock pilings in 10-20 feet of water. They love structure and aren't shy about hitting your bait. Spring through fall produces steady action, but they really turn on during cooler weather when they move shallow to feed. Guests love their feisty nature and the fact that they taste great fried up. They're perfect for kids since they bite readily and fight hard for their size. Here's a local secret: when you catch one rock bass, stick around that spot. They school up tight, so where there's one, there's usually a dozen more waiting.
Pittsburgh