Coney Island Creek is a River located in Kings County, NY. Starting in Brooklyn, NY the Coney Island Creek flows 4 miles through Brooklyn, NY before ending in Brooklyn, NY. Find maps, fishing guides, weather and recreation information at Guidesly.

About Coney Island Creek, NY

Coney Island Creek is a tidal inlet located in Brooklyn, New York that is 1.8 miles long. Before, it made Coney Island an actual island as it was a three-mile-long continual strait and a partial mudflat that linked Gravesend Bay, where its mouth is, and Sheepshead Bay. The creek stops at Shell Road where a storm drain emerges from under the road. The creek’s north end is adjoined by Calvert Vaux Park, Kaiser Park on the south end and Coney Island Creek Park in the west. The eastern part of the creek flows along a private industrial property. A cable net between Cropsey and Stillwell Avenues restricts marine traffic. 

In the 20th century, Coney Island Creek was still a minimally passable waterway when industries started to develop around it. As a result, it became polluted with substances like arsenic, cyanide and benzene. The northwestern part of the inlet is known as a ship graveyard while at its southern shore, the remains of a 45-feet yellow submarine called the Quester I sticks out of the water. Baptisms are also performed at the creek. The United States Environmental Protection Agency was considering dubbing the creek as a Superfund site during late 2020 due to concerns about pollution. 

All About Fishing in Coney Island Creek, NY

Fish reported to have been caught in Coney Island Creek include fluke, striped bass, bluefish, tub gurnard, pink dentex, Atlantic herring, Atlantic bonito, and barramundi. The area is also said to be very good to look for fluke. The inlet was once a bountiful source of different fish species and oysters. Shellfish and finfish were also prolific in its waters before its watershed drainage area became highly urbanized. It’s advised to check New York fishing regulations and fish consumption protocols before venturing to fish at the inlet due to records of pollution. 

The most common ways to catch fish at Coney Island Creek is by fly fishing and spinning. Anglers mostly do inshore fishing at the creek as there is access to piers and docks as well as the allowance of bank fishing. The inlet provides parking in the area and has access for wheelchairs. The creek is also family friendly with schools using it for outdoor excursions to learn about water life. The coast of the creek is not permitted for swimming. Visitors to the creek can also go to the nearby public parks that surround it. 

Fishing Seasonality

The open season for recreational fishing for fluke is between the months of May and September. Striped bass season is open from April to December. One can have a better chance of catching bluefish during the summer while herring make an appearance during the winter. Tub gurnards spawn from May through August while pink dentex breed from just March to May. Atlantic bonito could be generally caught all year round and has no daily catch and bag limits in the United States as it’s not a currently managed species. Anglers are urged to check for the local daily catch and bag limits for certain fish species as well as weather and water conditions.

Fishing Seasonality

The open season for recreational fishing for fluke is between the months of May and September. Striped bass season is open from April to December. One can have a better chance of catching bluefish during the summer while herring make an appearance during the winter. Tub gurnards spawn from May through August while pink dentex breed from just March to May. Atlantic bonito could be generally caught all year round and has no daily catch and bag limits in the United States as it’s not a currently managed species. Anglers are urged to check for the local daily catch and bag limits for certain fish species as well as weather and water conditions.

All About Fishing in Coney Island Creek, NY

Fish reported to have been caught in Coney Island Creek include fluke, striped bass, bluefish, tub gurnard, pink dentex, Atlantic herring, Atlantic bonito, and barramundi. The area is also said to be very good to look for fluke. The inlet was once a bountiful source of different fish species and oysters. Shellfish and finfish were also prolific in its waters before its watershed drainage area became highly urbanized. It’s advised to check New York fishing regulations and fish consumption protocols before venturing to fish at the inlet due to records of pollution. 

The most common ways to catch fish at Coney Island Creek is by fly fishing and spinning. Anglers mostly do inshore fishing at the creek as there is access to piers and docks as well as the allowance of bank fishing. The inlet provides parking in the area and has access for wheelchairs. The creek is also family friendly with schools using it for outdoor excursions to learn about water life. The coast of the creek is not permitted for swimming. Visitors to the creek can also go to the nearby public parks that surround it.