Fishing Charters in Cayuga

Milton Nieto

xtreme trophy fishing

This was my first time going after alligator gar. Milton put me on a giant if you want a true adventure go with Milton. He’s a lot of fun to go fishing with and he will put you on a monster gar. He definitely brings the awesome factor to alligator gar fishing 🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Milton Nieto

xtreme trophy fishing

I took my son, an avid bass fisherman, out for his 16th birthday, and he ended up landing a Gar close to 6 feet long. Even now, he lights up every time the trip comes up in conversation.

Milton Nieto

xtreme trophy fishing

We had a blast and Milton and Mike are super cool down to earth guys. If you love fishing like me then this is the trip you want! Thanks guys!

Milton Nieto

xtreme trophy fishing

Chasing Alligator Gar had always been on my bucket list, and Captain Milton made it happen—even in challenging conditions. He handled everything with skill and confidence, putting us right on the fish. He's the perfect blend of Texas hospitality and expert angling—fishing with him was a real pleasure.

Milton Nieto

xtreme trophy fishing

We may have only landed one fish, but we had a great time doing it! Our captain was not only entertaining but also knew his stuff—both when it came to the fish and the gear we used.

Milton Nieto

xtreme trophy fishing

Milton is great ! If you want to catch a monster you better get booked now !

Milton Nieto

xtreme trophy fishing

Milton Nieto is an outstanding guide—an excellent captain, skilled fisherman, and all-around great person. He was fantastic with my nine-year-old son, taking the time to explain each step along the way. He got us on fish quickly, and sure enough, we landed a monster gar! I can’t recommend him highly enough.

Milton Nieto

xtreme trophy fishing

I wanted to take my two boys on a fishing trip, and despite the chilly morning, it turned out to be completely worth it! Milton was fantastic with them—patient, attentive, and happy to answer all their questions. We did a full-day trip and had an amazing time from start to finish.